top of page
  • evan8471

Issues Affecting the Value of a Personal Injury Case


There are a number of other issues that affect the monetary value of a case. Some are specific to the person, some to the situation, and some to the other parties involved in your case.

Predated Injury

Many injuries are subject to attack based on that they predated the accident and therefore were not caused by it. Herniated and bulging discs cases, especially the latter, are always subject to the attack that the injury predated the accident. Inevitably, the insurance company hires a doctor to read the MRI showing the disc injury. Unless there is definitive proof that the injury is accident-related, the insurance’s company doctor will undoubtedly say that the injury was degenerative and not accident-related.

Professional Medical Opinion

A credible medical opinion indicating that a hernia is degenerative reduces the value of the case by 50% or more. Your doctor will have to confront this adverse opinion head on for you to have any chance of connecting the disc injury to the accident. Unlessyou can credibly prove this causal connection, you cannot receive compensation for this injury. (Remember, the plaintiff has the burden of proof.)

You will need an MD to make this connection for you. A chiropractor’s opinion will only get you so far. Perhaps a rebuttal by a chiropractor will add 10% back into the value of the case. A neurologist is best, although an orthopedic doctor or even a radiologist may suffice. A well-reasoned opinion by a respected neurologist, rebutting the insurance company doctor’s opinion as to, say, arthritis, may bring the case back to 80% of its full value.

Recent Posts

See All

Supreme Court Expands LGBTQ Rights

You may be wondering why Neil Gorsuch, a Conservative Supreme Court justice, wrote the majority opinion in this week’s landmark ruling for LGBTQ rights. The Supreme Court has rules that dictate which

Coronavirus and Injury Litigation

The COVID-19 pandemic is creating big problems for just about everyone. As a personal injury lawyer, I am thinking about you, my client. We all need to be prepared for cancelled medical appointments a

Coronavirus and Litigation

We all need to be prepared for cancelled medical appointments. As a personal injury lawyer, I am thinking about how to advise my clients. My clients’ physical therapy regimens are probably going to be


What Clients Say

"Add a testimonial and showcase positive feedback from a happy client or customer."
bottom of page